Monday, May 23, 2011

May--The Secret Daughter by Shilpi Somoya Gowda

This month, The Third Tuesday Book Club met and discussed The Secret Daughter by Shilpi Somoya Gowda. It was okay. It was a book about India. It was a book about the lives of women. It was a book about the lives of women in India. In other words: it's been done before, and in order to be a stand-out in this genre you have to be pretty darn mind-blowing. Needless to say, The Secret Daughter left our minds pretty un-blown.

In the spirit of last month's post, let us begin.

Vanessa loved the story, but she didn't like the ending at all. Vanessa was brave and brought her PIC Tallan (Partner in Crime, that is), despite the very high threat of kidnap posed by one Trisha of the FB Clan.

Jeanette read half of this book before falling asleep at her desk. When she awoke, she made up her own—completely inaccurate, and possibly politically incorrect—ending. So I guess that means she felt lukewarm toward the book, unlike how she feels about her man. She and he are still going strong, and things are heating up! Alright!

Vivian said Ahhhhhhh. Tallan seconded that motion.

Lynn said it was fine. It was easy to get through, and it was fine. That's it, just fine. Hey! You wanna what's not fine? What is more than fine? Olivia peed on the potty! Commence happy dancing and celebratory "no more paying for diapers!" cheer…now.

Dar had something profound to say: she identified with Asha's plight as an adoptee. She was able to understand the feelings that Asha described, and for that reason, Darline's connection to the book was stronger.

Christine forgets this book, because she read it a long time ago. She never contributes anyways, and so she was reluctant to destroy her reputation this time around. Next time, missy! Also—nice shirt:P

Jes is new. Greenbean.

Sue read this book. It was her least favourite India book. Oh and just to be clear—her book choice was NOT an India book. It was, however, about Indians. But they lived in Africa, so that's totally different!

Ashleigh read most of this book, and she is anxious to see how it ends. Don't hold your breath, sister. This ending was pretty un-spectacular.

Trisha liked Usha, but would have liked her more if she were some sort of blood-sucking fiend that wanted to find her birth parents only so that she could drink from the veins of her makers!

Jenn had the following gem to offer. Stuff from India should be exotic, and spicy. This book was not Indian at all. It was as bland as a Midwestern shepherd's pie. Jenn is special.

Jasu is not a member of this book club, but he deserves mention. He tore a rip in the strong seam that is our book club. Some of us felt that Jasu was a great man, when it was all said and done. I say no. He's nothing but a big ol' baby-killer. So his hands didn't do the deed—they still have that baby's blood all over them.

Anyways, that all being said, there have been the following changes made, all for the sake of higher education. Our own fashionista, Paddy K, has a night course in textiles for the next while, and so we made some light changes to the schedule.

The new schedule is as follows:

June is now Trisha. She picked The Passage by Justin Cronin. We will meet on Tues, June 21 at 7:30 pm in the usual place to discuss this big, big book.

July is now going to be Jeanette's pick: Best Laid Plans by Terry Fallis. (Tues July 19 at 7:30 pm)

August is now Paddy, with her already selected City of Bones by Cassandra Clara. (Tues Aug 16 at 7:30 pm)

Sept is Ashleigh. She selected One Day by David Nicholls. (Tues Sept 20 at 7:30 pm)

October 2011: Christine

November 2011: Lynn

December 2011: Christmas Dinner and Party Time!

January 2012: Jenn

If you have complaints or concerns about the list, please click here to submit a complaint to the Complaints Dept. I promise this form will get forwarded to someone who cares:)

Until next month,

Be excellent to each other.

No comments: